Britain’s slowdown in productivity growth has plagued the country for as long as I can remember. There are many factors to blame. The 2008 financial crisis, the resulting austerity measures, low investment, the dreaded Brexit, and, of course, COVID-19. Add in ten turbulent years of six different prime ministers and a disastrous Truss mini-budget, and it’s no wonder investors are timid and we are stuck in a rut.
Housing is in crisis. Years of weak wage growth have left households exposed to the rising cost of living. In 2025, 12.8% of graduates aged 21 to 24 were not in education, employment, or training, up from 10.1% in 2022, while those in employment are sweating under a student finance system that would make a loan shark envious.
More recently, the war in Iran has driven up UK gas prices, with Ineos chairman Sir Jim Ratcliffe saying that gas prices are now 12 times the level in the US. The pressure on many businesses, small and large, has become insurmountable, and many have simply chosen to close their doors. The road to “good growth in every postcode” has seldom looked so bleak.
We need to see change. In fact, that was the name of the manifesto of the latest Labour government, now led by Andy Burnham. Unlike his more conservative predecessor, Burnham has proposed one of the most radical reforms to governance in UK political history.
Drawing on his experience as Mayor of Greater Manchester and a strategy he calls “Manchesterism”, he has devised a key policy to devolve power away from Westminster and empower local authorities. The idea is that this will cut red tape and create space for a more bespoke, collaborative form of politics, with the long-term outcome being a supercharge to development and the economy.
The trilemma is that any reform must appease the bond markets, which remain flighty; satisfy the voters, for whom Labour pledged not to raise income tax; and, most importantly, solve problems quickly enough in today’s political climate.
The criticism has come hard and fast. A Reuters Breakingviews analysis warns that devolution may reshape politics without delivering the economic revival Burnham hopes for.
But it seems foolish to dismiss devolution on the basis that the UK has a history of being centralised. Research identifies the UK as one of the most regionally unbalanced countries in the industrialised world. Major reform is needed to tackle this disparity and propel the country out of its current rut.
Politics is about action and the courage to maintain public faith. The latter seems the tougher challenge: Sir Keir Starmer has shown that passivity not only guarantees the system will remain broken, but can also become a one-way ticket to early resignation.
Manchesterism is a fairly new approach in this country, and as such, there is little hard evidence that this reform will deliver the wider change needed. Opposers find this uncomfortable. Contrary to what Burnham would have you believe, the success of Manchester is, after all, not directly applicable to the rest of the country.
This is particularly relevant to rural communities. Labour now holds rural seats from Northumberland to Cornwall, and their residents are keen to see investment in their hollowed-out villages. They will be anxious to see how devolution will be implemented and how it will bring them growth. There is fear that Manchesterism will prioritise urban hubs, further alienating them.
In its 2020 evidence to Parliament, the UK2070 Commission described the UK as “the most centralised country in the developed world” and argued that this centralisation had been a major contributor to regional inequality. Devolution is needed to some extent if the country, not just London, is to thrive moving forward.
Following the strategy outlined by the commission, Burnham’s success could be twofold. The commission recommended replacing England’s ad hoc, deal-based system with a comprehensive framework based on a presumption of devolution. This could accelerate the repair of harmful Thatcherite policies that disproportionately affected Wales and the north of Britain, with Manchester as the gold standard. According to the Greater Manchester Combined Authority’s analysis of ONS data, Greater Manchester’s economy grew by an average of 3.1% a year between 2015 and 2023, compared with 1.5% across the UK. The prospect of replicating that success nationwide is exciting.
The second advantage for Burnham was summarised by economist Alexander Jan, who wrote in 2019 that “local politicians consistently outperform those from central government” in surveys on trust. Winning the hearts of tired and cynical Brits will be key if he wants to serve a (now rather rare) full term and win a general election. Unfortunately, the commission’s guidance and political reality are worlds apart. The reorganisation will be arduous, messy, and expensive. These types of reforms are a favourite prey for the populist right, who will, without doubt, cry out about bureaucracy and push for a catastrophic, DOGE-style clean-up.
Concerns have also been raised about local authorities’ reliability and whether they can be trusted with such power. Runaway spending in Woking borough led to a £1.2bn deficit in 2023, and public services were subsequently cut. This is yet another example of Tory mismanagement that has led to the situation in the UK today, but it is also part of a wider pattern of local authorities running their budgets into bankruptcy.
Burnham’s reform must replicate Manchester’s success, or we risk another failed scheme akin to “levelling up”. Crucially, he must find a way to replicate the success nationwide. Pockets of growth in major cities will be an improvement, but will not justify the expense of this reorganisation effort and will surely lose him the rural seats.
If successful, Britain could be stronger and more stable, and the bond markets will relax. Growth will be constructive, and we can take back control. If it fails, the country could fall to Reform UK, or worse still, Restore UK. As such, some may call Manchesterism a gambit. But the proof lies in Manchester. It has succeeded before; it can succeed again.
Regardless of the economic payoff, devolution could prove critical to the country in the near future. The war in Ukraine shows no signs of slowing, and the Russian threat is more dangerous than ever. As tensions across the globe heat up, British self-sufficiency is clearly the way forward if we are to protect our sovereignty.
Devolution is exactly what is needed to allow individual areas of the UK to rebuild their productive capability and remove barriers to development. We need to act quickly, and devolution seems the path of least resistance to achieving our goals.
We must slow the continuous over-investment in London. London is a linchpin, and without secondary powerhouse cities and a growing rural sector, a blitz on the capital will cripple the country completely. We must consider the future carefully and invest now, while the waters are relatively calm.
The parliamentary culture of infighting, filibustering and general sleaze is incompatible with the needs of modern Britain. Growth is desperately needed, and Parliament seems more a barrier than a solution. Manchesterism will not end these practices, but it offers hope for a system where policy is once again at the forefront of politics.
Burnham’s message is hopeful and inspiring. The British public are sick of the status quo, and sick of Parliament. It’s a pantomime of seriousness, with its Etonian customs, unsavoury jeering, poor attendance, and subsidised alcohol. A modernised approach will be warmly welcomed. Whether Manchesterism will provide that solution remains to be seen, but we voted for change, and we will all be glad to see it.
by Oscar Baum





